[ Home / Rules / Radio / Streams / Net Friends ] [ latest / a ] [ cel / digi / lum / vnt / art / sp / lit / co / media / kind / wap / gens ]

/vnt/ - Vidya / Tech

Beep boop son, beep boop.
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)

GIVE IT UP FOR DAY FIVE

...AND NOW...

...THE CHEETAHMEN



Relax...

Catalog

File: 1715738312517.jpg(601.12 KB, 3009x3264, s1om5ieaajx01.jpg)

 No.546

I've seen an old X250 and a X240 both going for about 100 bucks and I thought I'd pick it up. I need a cheap laptop for casual use and school and I'd rather spend money on a desktop than burn a hole in my wallet to get a desktop replacement that's about as portable as an old microcomputer. But is the old Thinkpad craze online legit? I'm always suspicious of trends and fads and nothing is more suspect than China bashing fools circlejerking over old machines. I've never owned a Thinkpad but some basic research online and it seems there is something to the hype train but are old Thinkpads really worth it or just a meme? Should I save to buy a newish model? And what's a good old Thinkpad for my use case? I just want something small (14 inches max), portable, and relatively modern and durable that can emulate some older PSOne games and run Linux.

 No.547

>>546
guy who has bought a bunch here
They are nice and comfy, but when people tell you about upgradability and such they arent lying, but also realistically aside from the ram+storage you are unlikely to change much else.
Any i5 series should be good enough if you know what to expect and can lower expectations/optimise workflow well enough. the x250 should be good and better than the x240 since that one has no mouse buttons whereas the x250 does.
I would recommend the x260 as the best modern old one since skylake has great battery, but 5th gen should also be good, also in my experience the x260 has some design issue that causes freezes.

the t480 is a good bang-for-buck as it is 8th gen and thus 4 physical cores + usb-c. I have had issues with wifi on that one though.

the x series is typically 12.5 inch so you'll want a T series for 14 inch. Same again though, 5th gen and onwards is best. I would suggest looking at the screens in any online listings to be sure you get something you're happy with.
1366x768 is standard on a lot of them, if you're aiming for 14inch then imo 1600x900 is a good res to aim for, or 1080p if you cant get that

 No.548

>>547
Thanks anon I'll take a look. The T480 looks pretty good but ideally I want something smaller 12.5 to 14 inch range. I'll take a look at the X260 and see if I can find one at a good price. I've heard keyboard maintenance on the X240 and 250 is a nightmare too.

 No.564

>>546
The X series ones are a lot different build quality than the T beware. Look up a take apart of one of each to see what I mean, the X series skimp out on a lot of good stuff that the T has. It doesn't really matter the 2 inch size difference imo. Also the T ones heat up less than the X and you can generally do more with them.

 No.565

If I had money to burn, I'd get a Frankenpad or a Panasonic Let's Note while the yen is weak. But everyone prioritizes different things.

 No.730

Don't buy anything newer than the T14 Gen1 AMDs. I picked up one last year and it has been a decent laptop for what I need it for. But it doesn't let you coreboot like the older ones and it requires some binary blobs. It'll probably get better support software wise as the years go on.

The T14 Gen1's are the last ones that come with an ethernet port. But the battery is internal and a bit of a pain to replace compared to older models (I haven't had to do it yet). I went for it because it came with a better screen than the older ones. Mine came with the touchscreen which I don't use but it had more nits than the others I could have picked up. You can drop-in second nvme drive and it has some other nice things. I wouldn't get the Intel CPU version of it due to worse support for things like the wifi chip and the worse performance/battery life.

Anything newer has soldered on RAM only I think. Mine came with 32GB of RAM split between the soldered RAM and an add-on RAM stick. I needed at least 32GB of RAM for what I do it on it (mild video editing and debugging some bloated software). Also wanted to future proof a little due to web browsers and software constantly getting bloated up over the years.

I run Guix on mine now. Still trying to replicate my Gentoo set-up I ran most of the years. I've had Arch on it before too but didn't want to deal with systemd. Everything werks. Just be careful not to delete the default secure boot keys because it'll brick the motherboard if you do.

I don't buy-in to older models being "more secure" since everything is backdoor'd anyway despite libre/coreboot. It is nice to have more control over the software though.

Thinkpads used to be a lot cheaper than they are now. The rampant e-celeb shilling and constant threads on them over the last decade or so has driven up the price some compared to years ago. They're really expensive outside of my country from what I've heard. I couldn't pay more than $300 for one.

It is true the keyboards are way better on older models. The one I have is claimed to have various issues but I type pretty fast and haven't run into them yet (fingers crossed). I figure there are enough on the used market that I'll pick up a replacement or do some kind of modification should it come to that.

I like mine. It compiles software really fast and has been very stable once I've gotten it set-up. If you're into NixOS pre-existing hardware configs exist for the entire thinkpad line. Lots of documentation on places like Arch and Gentoo wikis. I like my older ones too.

Just avoid anything made after T14 Gen1s and you should be good. Everything after is garbage and the T14 build quality compared to the older models is a step down. Still a solid machine though.

 No.731

File: 1734727020659.gif(53.07 KB, 700x921, all_seeing_lain.gif)

>>730
Wanted to add; The T and P-series are the ones you'll probably want to be looking at for anything kind of modern in the thinkpad line. P-series are basically T-series that are meant to be a desktop replacement. So you're typically trading worse battery life in exchange for slightly better performance. But since we're talking about laptops it's hard to take advantage of that extra speed due to throttling most of the time. Especially in these newer models that have gone all-in on the thin-copy-Macbook thing everyone is doing now.

Mine is pretty good about compiling software without throttling. It's better than my 12 year old aging desktop in that respect. But only because it has double the RAM and CPU cores. It has a hard time maintaining the CPU at full speed without getting hot and throttling down to save itself. You'll also want to make sure you have your profiles setup correctly so it doesn't murder your battery when off the A/C charger. By default a lot of distros don't set that stuff up correctly out of the box.

Avoid the L-series. The hardware may look tempting as a cheaper T-series but in reality the screen will always be worse and you're going to sacrifice built quality. I haven't handled an L14 in person but I hear the build quality and screens are pretty bad compared to the T14's.

You'll also want to avoid the "s" versions. By that I mean; T14 Gen 1 AMD and T14s Gen 1 AMD are not the same machine. The "s" versions are even thinner and do away with features to obtain that thinner profile. So you lose out on the ability to have add-on sticks of RAM or an ethernet port where you could have been able to get one otherwise for probably a cheaper price point.

You want the ethernet port. I know you're probably thinking
>it's a laptop! Why do I need one!?
but trust me you want it. It's much easier to debug problems when you can simply plug into the LAN and go from there and not have to screw around with getting WiFi working. On mine Wifi hasn't been a problem. Ironically, the Gen 1 AMDs come with an Intel WiFi chip with great support. Where the Gen 1 Intels come with some other WiFi chip with bad support. But this isn't always the case and it's kind of luck of the draw with these on the used market. You don't know exactly what you're getting until you get it in your hands and probe it to see what's exactly inside. They are offered in a bunch of different configurations hardware wise and each company buying in bulk bought slightly different config.

They are never worth buying brand new. Wait 3-4 years and pick one up cheap on the used market. You shouldn't pay more than $300. $400 tops for a Thinkpad. Even that I'd argue is too much for most of them.

The T14 I have actually has two ethernet ports. But one of them requires using some kind of dongle through the usb3 port to access it. I think the later models might have that kind of setup. In mine there is a dedicated NIC for the actual ethernet port then the other one that can only be accessed through the dongle. Obviously, not using a dongle is preferred.

A lot of them have the ability to hook up to a dock with such dongles built in. But I've heard support can be hit-or-miss with those outside of Windows. Later models are going more and more Windows-only. With the parent company ignoring Linux users. Even my 4-5 year old laptop has a ton of long standing issues in Linux related to battery life, dock and some other misc. issues in not-Windows world. This is a big change from the older laptops where Linux (well Ubuntu) was considered first class citizen and the parent company would regularly roll out BIOS updates and firmware fixes when issues were reported. The older the thinkpad the less issues you should expect of this nature.

Last but not least: Older thinkpads have a much better built quality compared to modern ones. Another long post I'm not going to make right now. Just be aware that the older the machine the better the build quality you should expect.

You need to balance out your needs and pick one that'll work best for you. Do you need 12+ hours battery life, a solid chassis built out of metal and can live with 15+ year old CPU? Something you'll just do mild text editing on and such? Then go for the older ones for sure. You can't get such things (excluding CPU) in a more modern thinkpad. If you need a lot of RAM and CPU cores you'll have to sacrifice some build quality and live with the more plastic-y chassis. It's still a solid machine. Much better than 99% of machines on the market under $1.5k. But it isn't as touch as the older ones.

Whatever you do don't fall for these scam artists selling old hardware with "linux out of the box" for $2k+ right now. You'll see a lot of people claiming those are great laptops. But they're mostly the same crappy hardware, same crappy Ubuntu/Debian+GNOME linux distro pre-installed with horrible customer support.

Really, the state of modern laptops is pretty grim. There is no reason why a 15-25 year old Thinkpad shouldn't last you a life time. The only reason they don't boils down to the same problem with all computers now: The need to use the web browser and interact with modern "platforms" if you want to do anything but mess around in Vi and Emacs.

So again rule of thumb: Don't buy anything newer than the T14 Gen 1 AMDs. Don't buy anything with Nividia mobile graphics (avoid the hybrid Intel+Nividia stuff like the plague). If you get Intel CPU make sure it's paired with Intel GPU and ONLY intel GPU. Avoid all "little s" thinbook models. Try to avoid buying one with a lower end screen (or plan to upgrade it right off with a cheap replacement from China). Try to get one with external battery that's easy to replace (and buy good replacements not the cheapest you can find from China). Try to get one with ethernet port that doesn't require dongle. Try to get one with the ability to replace keyboard/trackpad (you'll need to do it at some point over the course of the lifetime of the machine if you use it daily. Maybe a good idea to buy replacement parts now while they're still easy to come by). Try to buy one with the ability to upgrade the RAM (or plan to buy that with the machine if it doesn't already come with it). If you get one with soldered RAM make sure that's maxed out when you buy it (so you can really max it out when you do add in a stick and it'll run full speed). Try to get one with as much storage as you need (or plan to update it). Do your research about white/blacklisted SSD/NVMEs (later models are bad about this or require certain parts due to other reasons).

It seems like a maze to navigate but most of this stuff is well researched and there exist wikis to walk you through the pros/cons of each. Whatever you do. Don't overpay. There are tons of re-sellers on ebay selling these things cheap. Don't get tricked into paying a lot for a "maxed out" model that's really just $50 worth of parts and a machine they got for $100 that they're selling for $300+ due to so many suckers wanting one because they saw someone on youtube shilling them.

Sorry this got long. I hope it was helpful.

By the way if you care yes the touchscreen on the T14 I have just werks. No idea why anyone would want to use it and get finger prints all over their screen. But it works out of the box with everything I've tried it with.

 No.743

I really love the look and feel of those classic keyboards but I’ve heard X230s are now borderline unusable. I need it to run some flavor FreeBSD and be capable of web browsing and video streaming, word processing, maybe running some retro games an VNs in an emulator.

I don’t understand why laptop keyboards in the 2000s, even on low end models, felt so much better than what we have today. Obsession with slim?

 No.875

>>743
There's a trend of everything that's not bright and flashy getting worse.

 No.1220

>>743
My X230 is still doing pretty well for itself. The main issue it suffers is how low the screen resolution is, it gets difficult to browse some of the more obnoxious site designs out there. Hardware's hanging in there though. I don't know about FreeBSD but on Linux you can even squeeze basic Vulkan support out of the iGPU.

 No.1324

>>546
I had a T420s that I used as my main laptop for some time. It was pretty much perfect, save for the battery life being awful. If you're pretty much always next to an outlet, as I was, it wasn't a problem, but otherwise that would probably be a headache. I believe I got it for 120 bucks CAD.



[Return][Go to top] Catalog [Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Embed
Password(For file deletion.)
[ Home / Rules / Radio / Streams / Net Friends ] [ latest / a ] [ cel / digi / lum / vnt / art / sp / lit / co / media / kind / wap / gens ]