No.399
I've only watched the anime. I liked season 1 a lot, but lost interest during the theater performance part of last season. I just thought it looked silly with the whole emotions showing through their acting thing.
No.820
I went into it completely blind and I really enjoyed it, I was hooked and watched the two seasons, I then knew I wanted more of it and read the manga, which I was also hooked on
I was sad for a day after reading the final 20 something chapters
I really liked the reincarnation angle from Aqua's POV, I wish there was more of it and I also enjoyed the slice of life stuff with Aqua and Ruby in the later parts of the manga, I wish there was more of it too but there's lots of fanart to fill that void